Where am I?

HOME
  • COMMENT Blogs
Comment Central - Daniel Finkelstein's rolling guide to opinion on the web

Comment Central - Times Online - WBLG

« How can the BBC make Parliament more exciting? Turn up the volume | All Posts | 2006 - a year of bad ideas »

December 21, 2006

The truth will out, so let David Irving speak

This is what I had to say when Nazi apologist David Irving was jailed in Austria for denying the truth about the Holocaust:

It is difficult, even for me now, born in safety, free to bring up my sons as Jews, sitting at a desk typing my article in civilised Britain, it is difficult not to feel anger, rage at Irving. It is difficult not to wish him behind bars.

And I do feel rage. But I do not wish him behind bars, not for giving his opinion, not for delivering a lecture, however warped and horrible his opinion is. I still believe in the power of truth. And my belief in truth is what separates me from Irving.

And it is how I feel on his release. It should not be a criminal offence to deny the Holocaust.

Read the whole of my argument, here.

Posted by Daniel Finkelstein on December 21, 2006 in History | Permalink | Comments (4) | TrackBack (0) | Email this post

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/297284/7238209

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The truth will out, so let David Irving speak:

Comments

It's a pity such arguments even need to be made in 21st-Century Western Europe. Freedom of speech is the essence of democracy. Making Holocaust denial illegal is the beginning of a very long road leading away from democracy. At the far end of that road lies the sort of totalitarianism that, as it happens, Jews don't tend to fare so well under. On the other hand, with New Labour now drafting legislation concerning what time everybody must set their alarm clocks in the morning, making Christianity illegal, and giving special rights and privileges to Muslims, I'm not sure how much there is left to lose.

Posted by: Hip Gnosis | 21 Dec 2006 16:15:05

What would convince David Irving of the truth? Perhaps, an audience with the Pope? A trip to Autwitz?

Posted by: John Hirst | 21 Dec 2006 22:39:37

There is an additional aspect to this story which has not been reported. Whilst Austria has burnished its anti Nazi credentials during the Irving case, it has failed to hold any trials of Holocaust murderers since 1970. There are several suspects, including a self confessed killer, living untouched in Austria. Irving was given 3 years for lies but murderers are exempt. Why ?

Posted by: Roffey | 22 Dec 2006 15:52:59

If David Irving were a lone figure crying in the wilderness, one could perhaps see your point. But he ain’t, anything but. One of one of the most prominent, revolting and vociferous anti-Semites of the Islamist MPAC (and thus naturally a regular on Newsnight) sent him money to pay for is his defence, and Irving represents the respectable ‘academic’ Western front of ‘Holocaust denial’, which the nut in Iran made the subject of a conference.

Irving makes ‘Holocaust denial’ respectable among a large section of the Islamic population (and not only them), who would like nothing better than a repeat performance. Not a few Muslims (and others) use Irving as an excuse to vilify Jews. It may have been better not to send him to prison, (though why?), but having landed there, it seems a sheer waste of time to shed tears and be indignant at his fate.

If he is fool enough, and arrogant enough, to set foot in a country which makes Holocaust denial a crime, then he got what he deserved. Perhaps if a few of his Muslim admirers were treated in the same way in the UK, they might be just a little more reticent about airing their disgusting opinions whenever they feel moved to do so.

Posted by: Richard | 22 Dec 2006 23:32:15

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the author has approved them.

Your Writers

  • Daniel Finkelstein is Chief Leader Writer of The Times and writes a weekly column. Comment Central is his rolling guide to the best opinion on the web. Click here for more information on the blog. Alice Fishburn, the Online Comment Editor, will also be posting.

    Send us an E-Mail

    News from Times Online

    • UK News
    • Crime News
    • Education News
    • Environment News
    • Health News
    • Political News
    • Science News
    • World News
    • Iraq News
    • US News
    • Europe News
    • Middle East News
    • Asia News
    • Africa News
    • Technology News
    • Business News

Feeds

  • Click for RSS 2.0 feed

three random posts

Recent Comments

  • Kekkler on 10 guilty people they always say are innocent
  • Ricardo Benitez on Are Americans too racist to vote for Obama?
  • bruce on Are Americans too racist to vote for Obama?
  • vwcat on Are Americans too racist to vote for Obama?
  • Ziggidy on Are Americans too racist to vote for Obama?

Recent Posts

  • Today's Web Grab
  • Lost in political conversations?
  • It's a dog's vote
  • Obama fires up the grills
  • Magazine Rack - Issue 254

You might also like...

  • conservativehome
  • Oliver Kamm
  • Chris Dillow
  • Andrew Sullivan's Daily Dish
  • Arts & Letters Daily
  • Nick Robinson
  • Iain Dale
  • Guido Fawkes
  • Real Clear Politics
  • Clive Davis
  • Stephen Pollard
  • Times Comment
  • Times Online Weblogs
  • Daniel's Weekly Column
  • The Fink Tank
  • Benedict Brogan
  • Boulton and Co.
  • Dizzy Thinks
  • Justin Webb's America
  • Mickey Kaus

Categories

  • 2008 Presidential election
  • Afghanistan
  • Alan Johnson
  • Alastair Campbell
  • Alexanda Litvenenko
  • American Politics
  • Animals
  • Anti-semitism
  • Barack Obama
  • BBC
  • Bill Clinton
  • Blair vs Brown
  • Blair's greatest hits!
  • Blair's legacy
  • Books
  • Boris Johnson
  • Budget 2008
  • Camilla Cavendish
  • Campaign Ads
  • Cash for peerages
  • Celebrities
  • Christopher Hitchens
  • Chuck Colson Award
  • Civil liberties
  • Class
  • Columns in other papers
  • Comment Central Competitions
  • Comment Central interviews...
  • Comment Central lists
  • Conservative Party
  • Crime
  • Current Affairs
  • David Aaronovitch
  • David Cameron
  • Death of Childhood
  • Democratic party
  • Donald Rumsfeld
  • Drugs
  • Economics
  • Education
  • Elections
  • Environment
  • Europe
  • Film
  • Florence Nightingale Award
  • Food and Drink
  • Football
  • FORA TV programmes
  • Foreign News
  • France
  • Freedom of Information
  • Games
  • Gay rights
  • Gordon Brown
  • Guns
  • Health
  • Hillary Clinton
  • History
  • Home news
  • Homosexuality
  • Hungary
  • Immigration
  • Iran
  • Islam
  • Israel-Palestinian conflict
  • John McCain
  • John Reid
  • Judaism
  • Labour leadership
  • Labour Party
  • Latin America
  • Law
  • Liberal Democrats
  • Madeleine McCann
  • Magazine Rack
  • Maps
  • Mariah Carey
  • Mary Ann Sieghart
  • Mathematics
  • Matthew Parris
  • Media
  • Middle East
  • Miscellaneous
  • Music
  • Name a Times Columnist!
  • New thread
  • NHS
  • North Korea
  • Northern Ireland
  • O.J. Simpson
  • Obesity
  • Obituaries
  • Opinion polls
  • Other newspapers
  • Paris Hilton
  • Parliament
  • Party conferences
  • Pervez Musharraf
  • Petitions
  • Podcasts
  • Political gift guide
  • Political memorabilia
  • President George W Bush
  • Profiles
  • Psychics
  • Race
  • Religion
  • Republican party
  • Rudy Giuliani
  • Science
  • Scotland
  • Sign up to support Sir Ringo!
  • Simon Barnes
  • Social policy
  • Sport
  • Sports
  • Stephen Colbert
  • Strategy Memo
  • Sudan
  • Tax
  • Television
  • Terrorism
  • Thailand's coup
  • The Beatles
  • The Brown manifesto
  • The Catholic Church
  • The Daily Fix
  • The Long Tail
  • The Message Meter
  • The Middle East
  • The War on Terror
  • Tim Hames
  • Times Columnist
  • Times story
  • Today in Times Comment
  • Tony Blair
  • Transport
  • Travel
  • Trident
  • Twofer interviews
  • UKIP
  • United Nations
  • Universities
  • Video
  • War in Iraq
  • Web Grab
  • Web/Tech
  • Weblogs
  • Weekend Central
  • Women

Archives

  • 29 June 2008 - 5 July 2008
  • 22 June 2008 - 28 June 2008
  • 15 June 2008 - 21 June 2008
  • 8 June 2008 - 14 June 2008
  • 1 June 2008 - 7 June 2008
  • 25 May 2008 - 31 May 2008
  • 18 May 2008 - 24 May 2008
  • 11 May 2008 - 17 May 2008
  • 4 May 2008 - 10 May 2008
  • 27 April 2008 - 3 May 2008

Other Times Online Blogs

  • Faith Central

    Urban Dirt

    Alpha Mummy

    BabyBarista

    Ariel Leve

    Big Brother Celebrity Hijack

    Charles Bremner

    Comment Central

    Cricket

    Eco Worrier

    Formula One

    India Knight

    Inside Iraq

    Irwin Stelzer

    Lord Rees-Mogg

    Mary Beard (TLS)

    Money Central

    News

    Sports Commentary

    Peter Stothard (TLS)

    Richard Lloyd Parry

    Ruth Gledhill

    Surf Nation

    Technology

    The Click