Where am I?

HOME
  • COMMENT BLOGS Comment Central

Comment Central - Times Online - WBLG

« Remember this? | All Posts | Magazine Rack - Issue 357 »

December 01, 2008

Is Hillary's appointment unconstitutional?

Hillary_s_of_s

Could Hillary Clinton's appointment be unconstitutional? Ben Smith thinks it could be:

With Hillary's expected appointment tomorrow comes a round of buzz about "emoluments" and specifically the question of whether, under a fairly straightforward reading of the Constitution, her appointment isn't constitutional.

At issue is Article I, Section 6, which says, "No Senator or Representative shall, during the Time for which he was elected, be appointed to any civil Office under the Authority of the United States which shall have been created, or the Emoluments whereof shall have been increased during such time." That is, if the Cabinet, or other, post got a pay hike during the term of the senator, the senator couldn't take the job. During Clinton's Senate term, Bush raised the Cabinet's pay.

And there are serious lawyers who see this, legally speaking, as a real obstacle.

However, there have been other occasions when this has arisen - the appointment of Llyod Bentsen as Treasury Secretary for instance. The solution is to cut the salary of the incoming Senator/Secretary.

Posted by Daniel Finkelstein on December 01, 2008 at 01:09 PM in Hillary Clinton | Permalink Bookmark and Share

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451586c69e201053626678f970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Is Hillary's appointment unconstitutional?:

Comments

Is Hillary's appointment unconstitutional?

Hillary_s_of_s

Could Hillary Clinton's appointment be unconstitutional? Ben Smith thinks it could be:

With Hillary's expected appointment tomorrow comes a round of buzz about "emoluments" and specifically the question of whether, under a fairly straightforward reading of the Constitution, her appointment isn't constitutional.

At issue is Article I, Section 6, which says, "No Senator or Representative shall, during the Time for which he was elected, be appointed to any civil Office under the Authority of the United States which shall have been created, or the Emoluments whereof shall have been increased during such time." That is, if the Cabinet, or other, post got a pay hike during the term of the senator, the senator couldn't take the job. During Clinton's Senate term, Bush raised the Cabinet's pay.

And there are serious lawyers who see this, legally speaking, as a real obstacle.

However, there have been other occasions when this has arisen - the appointment of Llyod Bentsen as Treasury Secretary for instance. The solution is to cut the salary of the incoming Senator/Secretary.

  • Your writers

    Daniel Finkelstein,
    is Chief Leader Writer of The Times and writes a weekly column. Comment Central is his rolling guide to the best opinion on the web.
    Hattie Garlick, the Online Comment Editor, will also be posting.

    Send us an email

    Click here for more information on the blog.

    Latest posts

    Latest comments

    Categories

    Select from the dropdown

You might also like...

  • 2008 Presidential election
  • Justin Webb's America
  • Boulton and Co.
  • Benedict Brogan
  • Dizzy Thinks
  • Chris Dillow
  • The Fink Tank
  • Daniel's Weekly Column
  • Oliver Kamm
  • Stephen Pollard
  • Iain Dale
  • Nick Robinson
  • Guido Fawkes
  • Conservative Home
  • Clive Davis
  • Arts & Letters Daily
  • Liam Murray
  • Marbury
  • Real Clear Politics
  • Andrew Sullivan's Daily Dish
  • Mickey Kaus
  • Political Betting
  • Times Online Weblogs
  • Times Comment

News from
Times Online

  • UK
  • Crime
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Health
  • Political
  • Science
  • World
  • Iraq
  • US
  • Europe
  • Middle East
  • Asia
  • Africa
  • Technology
  • Business
  • US Elections
Other Times Online blogs
  • Sports Book
  • Boxing
  • Alpha Mummy
  • Line and Length
  • The Game
  • Fanzine Fanzone
  • Formula 1
  • Rugby league
  • Sports Commentary
  • Technology