Where am I?

HOME
  • COMMENT Blogs
Times Online Faith Central blog

Faith Central - Times Online - WBLG

« Tips for Ramadan from around the world | All Posts | Moses and the High School Musical »

September 13, 2007

Crucifixion: was it illegal?

The_trial_of_christThis has to be one of the oddest lawsuits on record.  A group of Christians in Kenya are trying to get the Crucifixion of Christ ruled illegal, citing as respondents the Emperor Tiberius, Pontius Pilate,the Jewish Chief Priest, elders and Teachers.  Oh, and King Herod.  The Kenya Civil Liberties Union has joined the proceedings as amicus curiae (friend of the court). There is dispute about the "urgency" claimed.
    On one level this is benign, if eccentric: the advocate says he seeks to challenge the abuses in criminal prosecutions, by showing the origin of them in this particular injustice.  On the other hand, read the list of respondents again. It opens the door to some pretty nasty anti-Semitism of the kind common in the Middle Ages.
      And what, exactly, do they see as a good outcome?  A posthumous pardon for the Son of God? 

Posted by Libby Purves on September 13, 2007 at 02:51 PM in The Crucifixion | Permalink Bookmark and Share

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451586c69e200e54ef143fa8834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Crucifixion: was it illegal?:

Comments

You can't blame the Catholic Church this time for this idiocy! A ridiculous piece of buffoonery like this simply brings all genuine Christianity into disrepute and gives the atheists another stick with which to beat their straw men.

Posted by: Geoffrey Smith | 13 Sep 2007 16:22:01

If the Kenyan's can't sort out Arap Moi's illegality, how on earth will they sort out God's Law?

Posted by: Ian | 15 Sep 2007 01:34:20

Would a posthumous pardon for the Son of God undo his work of penal substitution?

Posted by: Christopher | 15 Sep 2007 08:50:41

This actually raises a big theological question: Did Christ come to Earth to die?

If Pilate had followed through with his finding of non-guilt in Jesus and released him instead of Barabas, would another way have been found to kill the Son of God?

Posted by: Cosmo | 15 Sep 2007 23:22:34

May I point out that it is practically impossible that the Jewish community, High Priests or anyone else, could have been reponsible (even indirectly) for the crucifixion.

Despite beliefs to the contrary, capital punishment was in practice against Jewish law, as witnesses were needed in all cases. The Bible was not taken literally, but was attenuated by use of Oral Law.

This is, by the way, why the present State of Israel abolished the death penalty, which they had inherited from the British Mandate, as soon as they became independent in 1948.

I realise that this statement might cause a storm, but it is the truth.

Posted by: Dr. Irene Lancaster FRSA | 16 Sep 2007 21:51:12

But Irene, didn't they hang Adolf Eichmann in 1962?

Posted by: Christopher | 17 Sep 2007 13:46:30

Yeah Irene,
What do you call house demolition while the occupants are inside if not capital punishment for what their relatives did.
Or what do you call shooting dead palestinian kids for what the older ones did if not capital punishment.
Face it Irene, the nation state of Israel is nothing to do with God, and because they retain the cherem on Jesus neither are its people.
Nonetheless, Jesus was murdered in Sodom & Egypt,

Posted by: Ian | 18 Sep 2007 10:56:49

Now I see.

Posted by: Ian | 20 Sep 2007 00:57:16

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the author has approved them.

Libby Purves

  • Libby Purves is a Times columnist, novelist and Radio 4 broadcaster. Her interest in the glories, inspirations and eccentricities of world religions and cultural traditions was fuelled by an upbringing in Bangkok, Israel, Africa, France and a series of convent schools.

    Bess Twiston Davies works for the Times Register section and is a regular contributor to the Faith page and Times Online. She studied Hispanic studies and English at Sheffield University and has a journalism diploma from The Robert Schuman Institute, Angers, France.


    Contact Libby or Bess at: faithcentral@timesonline.co.uk

    You might also enjoy Articles of Faith, Ruth Gledhill's wonderful blog about religious affairs.

RSS Feeds

  • Click for an RSS 2.0 feed

Recent Comments

  • Rokeby on Top 10 macho hymns for Men
  • John on Eygpt´s "headscarf martyr"
  • Ban on Eygpt´s "headscarf martyr"
  • M.Robinson on Hindu scientists say astrology can prevent heart attacks
  • Irf on Eygpt´s "headscarf martyr"
  • Irf on Eygpt´s "headscarf martyr"
  • Milly on Top 10 macho hymns for Men
  • iain rae on Turkish reality tv show to convert atheists
  • JAMES SASSE on Saudi women drivers?
  • Mehedi on Eygpt´s "headscarf martyr"

Recent Posts

  • Hindu scientists say astrology can prevent heart attacks
  • Eygpt´s "headscarf martyr"
  • Turkish reality tv show to convert atheists
  • Jihadi Soccer - the Saudi Fatwa
  • "Gays are not Godless" reveals new survey
  • Was Michael Jackson Muslim?
  • Tweeting the world's faiths
  • How many Muslims live in Germany?
  • Nurse told her Crucifix is an infection risk
  • Scientology leader accused of violence

Links

  • Lambeth Conference 2008

Categories

  • "Honour" killings
  • 'Islamic' Jesus
  • A year of living biblically
  • Abolition
  • Abortion
  • Abuse
  • Adultery
  • Advent calendars
  • Afghanistan
  • Ahmadinejad
  • Aids
  • al-Qaeda
  • Alcohol
  • Allah
  • Alpha Course
  • Anglicanism
  • Animal sacrifice
  • Apocalypse
  • Apostasy
  • Apple
  • Archaeology
  • Archbishop of Canterbury
  • Assyriology
  • Asylum
  • Atheism
  • Atheist Sunday School
  • Australia
  • Ballooning priest
  • Bank Holiday
  • Baptism
  • Barack Obama
  • Barbie in a burka
  • Benazir Bhutto
  • Biblical recipes
  • Big Mac
  • Bishop Michael Nazir Ali
  • Bishop wants hell removed from Bible
  • Blasphemy__
  • Blogging
  • Bob Dylan
  • Books
  • Botox
  • Britney Spears
  • Broadband in the belfry
  • Buddha's tree
  • Buddhism
  • Bumper stickers
  • Burma
  • Cafe where you pay by praying
  • Caliphate
  • Cambodia
  • Camel beauty contests
  • Cannibalism
  • Canonization
  • Capital Punishment
  • Carols
  • Cathedrals
  • Catholicism
  • Celebrity
  • Chastity
  • Child abuse
  • China
  • Christian Atheism
  • Christianity
  • Christmas
  • Church and state
  • Church of England
  • Church thieves
  • citizenship
  • Climate Change
  • Comment Central
  • Commission on Integration
  • Condoms
  • Confucianism
  • Conversion
  • Creationism
  • Cuba
  • Cycling
  • Da Vinci
  • Diana Princess of Wales
  • Disappearance
  • Diwali
  • Dr Who
  • Drugs
  • Earthquake
  • Easter
  • eBay
  • Edinburgh Fringe
  • Edith Piaf
  • Education
  • Eid
  • Electric shocks
  • Electronic Rosary
  • Elvis
  • Emailing God
  • Employment
  • Environment
  • Epitaphs
  • Euthanasia
  • Evangelism
  • Exam howlers
  • Execution
  • Extraordinary burial techniques
  • Extreme pilgrim
  • Facebook
  • Faith Central
  • Faith Schools
  • Female 'circumcision'
  • Floods
  • Flying Spaghetti Monster
  • Forgiveness
  • France
  • Fresco
  • Fundamentalist Church of the Latter Day Saints
  • Gambling
  • Gandhi
  • Gangsters' '10 commandments'
  • Gaza
  • George Bush
  • Gideon Bibles
  • Goddess
  • Godtube
  • Golf
  • Good Samaritan
  • Google
  • Gordon Brown
  • Gospel Music
  • Gossip
  • Hadith
  • Haj
  • Halal meat
  • Halloween
  • Haram products
  • Harry Potter
  • High School Musical
  • Hinduism
  • Holocaust
  • Holy Robots
  • Homelessness
  • Homer Simpson
  • Homophobia
  • Homosexuality
  • Hospital chaplains
  • Human fertilisation and embryology bill
  • Human Rights
  • Ice church
  • iGod
  • Imams
  • Indian nun and self-harm
  • Indulgences
  • Infertility
  • Ingmar Bergman
  • Inter-faith
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Islam
  • Islamic Art
  • Islamic Barbie
  • Israel
  • James Bond and religion
  • Jedi Church
  • Jehovah's Witnesses
  • Jerusalem
  • Jerusalem banned from Cathedral
  • Jesuits
  • Jesus
  • Jewish 'hijab'
  • Jihad
  • Jonathan Edwards
  • Judaism
  • Koran
  • Kosher
  • Last Supper
  • Latin Mass
  • Lattevangelism
  • Lazer monks
  • League table of religions
  • Lech Kaczynski
  • Lent
  • Life of Jesus
  • Litigation
  • LOLcat Bible
  • Longevity
  • Luck
  • Madrassa
  • Magic
  • Maharishi Mahesh Yogi
  • Maldives
  • Map of sin
  • Marriage
  • Martin Luther
  • Media
  • Medicine
  • Medjugorje
  • Middle East peace process
  • Military
  • Misbah Rana
  • Missionaries
  • Mobile phones
  • Morality
  • Mormonism
  • Mosques
  • Mother Earth
  • Mother Teresa
  • Motorcycling
  • Music
  • Muslims
  • National Secular Society
  • Nativity plays
  • Noah's Ark
  • Northern Ireland
  • Number of the Beast
  • Olympics
  • Olympics, human rights
  • Orange Order
  • Organ Donation_
  • Organists
  • Ossuary
  • Outsourcing
  • Oxford
  • Oxford University
  • Paganism
  • Park and Pray
  • Pay per view church
  • Persecution
  • Pervez Kambaksh
  • Philip Pullman
  • Pilgrims
  • Planet Atheist
  • Poland
  • Politics
  • Pope
  • Pornography
  • Prayer
  • Prayer booth
  • Presidential race
  • Prince Charles
  • Quakers
  • Quiz
  • Rapping monk
  • Red Mosque
  • Relics
  • Religion
  • Religion and shoes
  • Religions of cartoon characters
  • Religious animals
  • Religious beer
  • Religious dieting
  • Religious education
  • Remembrance Sunday
  • Revolution
  • Richard Dawkins
  • Robert Putnam
  • Robotic Bible writer
  • Romania
  • Rosaries
  • Royalty
  • Rugby
  • Russia
  • Ruth Kelly
  • Sacred
  • Saints
  • Sania Mirza and Shahar Meer
  • Sante Muerte_
  • Sarkozy
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Saudi religious law
  • Science
  • Scientology
  • Scouting
  • Second Life
  • Secularism
  • Segregation
  • Seven deadly sins revised
  • Sex
  • Sex education
  • Sex scenes
  • Shari'a
  • Shi'a Islam
  • Sikhs
  • Sky Kingdom
  • Southern Baptists
  • Space
  • st george
  • Sudan
  • Sun Worship
  • Tablighi Jamaat
  • Tankinis
  • Terror attacks
  • Terrorism
  • The Bible from the Air
  • The Crucifixion
  • The Enlightenment
  • The literary Canon
  • The new seven wonders of the world
  • The people vs God
  • The Ten Commandments - Cowboy style
  • The veil
  • The world's most stable country
  • Tibet
  • Tom and Jerry "a Jewish conspiracy"
  • Tony Blair
  • Top ten religious treats
  • Top twenty religious t shirts
  • Trinny and Susannah
  • Tutankhamun
  • US elections
  • Uzbekistan
  • Valentine's Day
  • Vatican
  • Video games
  • Voodoo
  • Warrior Nun
  • Web/Tech
  • Weddings
  • Westboro Baptist Church
  • Wiccans
  • Witchcraft
  • Women
  • World Youth Day
  • World's most powerful religious leaders
  • Yazidis
  • Zimbabwe
  • Zoroastrianism

Other Times Online Blogs

  • Faith Central

    Urban Dirt

    Alpha Mummy

    BabyBarista

    Ariel Leve

    Big Brother Celebrity Hijack

    Charles Bremner

    Comment Central

    Cricket

    Eco Worrier

    Formula One

    India Knight

    Inside Iraq

    Irwin Stelzer

    Lord Rees-Mogg

    Mary Beard (TLS)

    Money Central

    News

    Sports Commentary

    Peter Stothard (TLS)

    Richard Lloyd Parry

    Ruth Gledhill

    Surf Nation

    Technology

    The Click

Archives

  • July 2009
  • June 2009
  • May 2009
  • April 2009
  • March 2009
  • February 2009
  • January 2009
  • December 2008
  • November 2008
  • October 2008