Where am I?

HOME
  • SPORT Fanzine Fanzone

Fanzine Fanzone - Times Online - WBLG

Leading football fanzine editors join the debate on Times Online http://timesonline.typepad.com/fanzine_fanzone/rss.xml

« The wonder of wingers | All Posts | 6 Strikers, 9 Games, 1 Goal - Exeter's Number Game »

September 23, 2008

Pound of flesh - £30 million

TevezYes I know this is wearily predictable, but I can't resist the temptation. Today's news that an independent tribunal has ruled against West Ham, and for Sheffield United, in the Carlos Tevez affair is laughable. I mean, I'm not laughing, but you get my point.

The crux of my nub is this statement, published in the Daily Mail today:
"On the totality of the evidence, we have no doubt that West Ham would have secured at least three fewer points over the 2006/07 season if Carlos Tevez had not been playing for the club."

Oh yeah? Let's look at the evidence, shall we?

Tevez played well towards the end of the season - really well. He famously scored the only goal of our last game of the season at Old Trafford, and I almost wish he hadn't. That game was won through a heroic effort by every member of our team, but the only fact that registers with the tribunal members is
Man Utd 0 - 1 West Ham (Teves)
That's three points right there, and proof of our guilt.

Never mind that the arrival of Teves and Mascherano was accompanied by absolute chaos, a double signing that took even our manager, Alan Pardew by surprise. Fitting them into the side was an immediate problem, which Pardew solved by  leaving Mascherano on the bench. Results were poor, despite these two undeniably brilliant players in the squad, and eventually Pardew paid with his job.

At this point, how many points had Tevez gained West Ham? To make any kind of intelligent judgment, you have to consider how many points we might have had without him. The previous season, we finished ninth and reached the FA Cup final, qualifying for Europe. So why were we suddenly stuck in the relegation zone?

If any part of our struggles was connected with the arrival of Tevez and Mascherano - and the associated stress and controversy - then thos players actually cost West Ham points.

This may sound like a fatuous point - a one-eyed fan trying to wriggle out of a moral pinch - but it's actually a relatively sophisticated argument. The truth is, the amount of points that one player gains for his team is completely unknowable.

The problem is, the members of the tribunal don't seem to be capable of a sophisticated judgment. And why not?

Because the members of the board were:
Robert Englehart QC, an expert in sport law, but with no apparent knowledge of football
Lord Griffiths, former MCC president and keen golfer
Sir Anthony Colman, former high court judge with no connection to sport of any kind

Let's not have people like this making decisions about the game, OK? Yes, they can argue the legal points, but no, they cannot tell how many points West Ham would have ended the season with if they hadn't signed Carlos Tevez.

Nobody can know that, and it would take an extremely arrogant group of men to think - despite an unplumbable depth of ignorance of the game - that they could.

Douglas Carter

Technorati Tags: Sheffield United, tribunal, West Ham

Posted at 06:20 PM in West Ham United | Permalink Bookmark and Share

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451586c69e2010534c18a71970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Pound of flesh - £30 million :

Comments

Pound of flesh - £30 million

TevezYes I know this is wearily predictable, but I can't resist the temptation. Today's news that an independent tribunal has ruled against West Ham, and for Sheffield United, in the Carlos Tevez affair is laughable. I mean, I'm not laughing, but you get my point.

The crux of my nub is this statement, published in the Daily Mail today:
"On the totality of the evidence, we have no doubt that West Ham would have secured at least three fewer points over the 2006/07 season if Carlos Tevez had not been playing for the club."

Oh yeah? Let's look at the evidence, shall we?

  • Arsenal

    All Arsenal posts, Subscribe via RSS

    Bristol City

    All Bristol City posts
    Subscribe via RSS

    Celtic

    All Celtic posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Chelsea City

    CFCnet, All Chelsea posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Derby

    Ram Space, All Derby posts Subscribe via RSS

    Everton

    Dixie's Sixty, All Everton posts, Subscribe via RSS

    Exeter City

    Vital Exeter City, All Exeter City posts, Subscribe via RSS

    FSF

    Football Supporters' Fed,
    All FSF posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    FFC

    Craven Cottage Newsround, All Fullham posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Hearts

    All Hearts posts, Subscribe via RSS

    Liverpool

    All Liverpool posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Man City

    Blue Moon, All Man City posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Man Utd

    All Man Utd posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Middlesbrough

    Boro Brick Road, All Middlesbrough posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Newcastle Utd

    True Faith, All Newcastle Utd posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Portsmouth

    Pompey Fans, All Portsmouth posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Sheffield Utd

    All Sheffield Utd posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Spurs

    My Eyes Have Seen the Glory
    All Spurs posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Stoke

    All Stoke posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Sunderland

    A Love Supreme, All Sunderland posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    Wigan

    Wiganer, All Wigan posts,
    Subscribe via RSS

    JOIN THE FANZONE

    Get it off your chest
    Want to have your say? It's time to join the best biased football forum on the planet

    PLAY THE GAME

    The most realistic Fantasy Football game is back for the 2009/10 season

    AHEAD OF THE GAME

    Sign up for our free daily email, weekdays 4pm

    THE GAME
    THE NEWS
    PLAY THE GAME

    The most realistic Fantasy Football game is back for the 2009/10 season

    YOUR WEB
    • Soccerbase
    • Football 365
    • Who ate all the pies?
    • You Tube
    • Football Shirt Culture
    • News Now
    • Fanbase
    • Pyramid Passion
    • Mike Floate's Football Ground Frenzy
    • The Spoiler
    • 101 Great goals
    • Kickette
    • Newcastle United Blog

    Archives

    • View previous blog posts

    Feeds

    Get the latest news and comments via RSS

    All the latest from Fanzine Fanzone

    All the reader comments

    All the posts from TheGame

    A complete list of all Times Online Sport stories

    Use the buttons below to add the feeds to your RSS reader, or right the links above, click and choose "save target as", then paste the url into your RSS reader.

    For more information on using RSS, and for more feeds from Times Online, visit

    the main RSS page

    Bloglines
    Google
    Yahoo!
    Netvibes