The Doosra - Cricket Blog - Times Online - WBLG

Bowling, Shane!

Just over a fortnight ago, the doosra asked you to pick the greatest spinner of all time. Over 1800 people voted, and the result is pretty conclusive. The two perfect-10 men, Jim Laker and Anil Kumble, got their fair share of votes, but the leaders of the pack are miles ahead. More than one in three plumped for the elastic wrists and guile of Muttiah Muralitharan, but the winner by a distance - with nearly half the votes - is the man who was known as the Sheik of Tweak and Hollywood amongst other things. When we look back on the 1990s and much of the first decade of the new millennium, one of the enduring images will be of an Australian wicketkeeper shouting: "Bowling, Shane" after a legbreak, flipper or zooter had bamboozled the batsman.

Who is the greatest spinner ever?

It's become commonplace each time the relative merits of Muttiah Muralitharan and Shane Warne are discussed to use the descriptor: the greatest spinner ever. Such sweeping statements though border on the disrespectful and ignore the claims of some of the game's greats. Even if you overlook 19th century titans like Bobby Peel and Johnny Briggs on the grounds that no one even saw grainy newsreel footage of them in action, there are at least a half a dozen others with claims to top-dog status.

Bill O'Reilly, whose battles with Don Bradman illuminated Australian domestic cricket between the wars, would feature in any such discussion, as would a Yorkshireman, Hedley Verity. South Africa's Hugh Tayfield ploughed a lone furrow for years, and many still get misty-eyed about India's legendary spin quartet.

The Doosra offers up nine names - there will, no doubt, be many complaints over the exclusion of Abdul Qadir and Derek Underwood - and invites you to pick your number one. The stats say that Murali and Warne are a class apart. Do you agree?

Voting has now closed, and below are the results: